Hey, Blog Coach: What’s a Trackback?

"What’s a Trackback?"

This is a question often asked. I’ll explain the techno-stuff towards the end, but let’s get to real question: When Should I Use a Trackback?

A trackback is a way to elaborate or expand upon a blog post from someone else’s blog. A perfect example of a trackback can be found on my previous post here: Synchronize Your Communications.

Alan Hoffler of MillsWyck Communications offered a trackback to the post, pointing back to his own article, How Accessible Are You? Here’s why this is a great example:

  • Rather than just repeating what I said, Alan goes into depth about expectations in communication – elaborating on what I wrote
  • Both posts are introduced to our respective audiences, and each audience benefits
  • Each has it’s own message, though they are connected because of the subject matter

When is a trackback not such a good idea? When you’re simply repeating what the original author said in their post – it’s probably not wise to trackback. I call this a "loopback" since all you’re doing is sending the original audience back to where they started – with little, if any, new thought.

Of course, some blogs allow only trackbacks, but no comments. Same principle applies. If you’re adding to the idea, trackback. If not, just a simple link out from your blog will do nicely:-)

Now, to the techno-stuff (I’ll cut to the quick).

A trackback (definition) is essentially a "ping" that gets delivered to the original article. When a trackback is used, most blogware is set-up to communicate this "ping" and note it just above the comments – if the author accepts trackbacks.

Here’s how to send a trackback in TypePad. Blogger has a similar feature called Backlinks. If you’re looking for the trackback in WordPress blogs, you’ll most likely find it on the individual article page (click the headline).

In June, I wrote that Long Comments Should be Posts. I’ll stand by that thought, and suggest that it’s in those cases – and Alan’s example above – that a trackback makes sense.

Note: I did NOT use the trackback feature from this post back to Alan’s post. First, it goes off on a different subject. Second, it would end up being a loop.

Follow on Twitter or Facebook or on Google+

Find Your Social Media ROI

I hear it from a lot of business owners: “Where is the ROI with all this Social Media?“ If this is a question you ask yourself, maybe we should work together a bit more. We can work together solo, or via a professional learning community. Find and increase your ROI. There is a “there” there.

  • http://www.zoominfo.com/Search/PersonDetail.aspx?PersonID=-87134 Susan Cergol

    Mike, I always learn something new from your site and really value your expertise. As a newbie blogger, I especially appreciate how you integrate the technical aspects of blogging while answering the basic question “Why should I care about this?”
    Reminds me of Kathy Sierra’s recent post “Are Your Users Stuck in ‘P’ Mode?” (Creating Passionate Users blog) about the importance of teaching people not just how to use a new tool or product, but why. As she put it, “What good does it do to master a tool if we haven’t understood (let alone mastered) the thing we’re using the tool for?”
    Thanks for helping me find my way!

  • http://getanewbrowser.com Andy Brudtkuhl

    I will play devil’s advocate on this one and note that I do not like trackbacks for several reasons. And, for the most part we have stopped using them at GANB.
    1. Spam problems
    2. 90% of the time they are used incorrectly (posts like this should help clarify, thanks)
    3. There are many service (PubSub, Technorati, Search Engines) to do this work for us
    http://jeremy.zawodny.com/blog/archives/005049.html

  • http://www.converstations.com Mike Sansone

    Hi Susan, Thanks for your kind words. That kind of reinforcement will propel me forward should I face any turbelence.

  • http://www.converstations.com Mike Sansone

    Thanks, Andy. Great job at pointing out the negatives of trackbacks. You filled a gap. Each of three points are valid, but as you point out parenthetically – it doesn’t stop the question from getting asked.
    If everyone looked at trackbacks to benefit others, it would be put to better use. Unfortunately, too many use it to drive traffic to their own site – which is what made them a trouble spot.

  • http://www.brainbasedbusiness.com Ellen Weber

    Mike, I love the way to get through the points and share the counterpoints — while missing the fog. I hadn’t thought of the negatives either. You are right that we avoid these when we use trackbacks in ways they were intended to be used. When too much effort is placed on traffic we fail to communicate well as humans in these. Thanks for the reminders here!

  • http://www.converstations.com Mike Sansone

    Thanks Ellen, It’s only because I was once in the fog that I can assist in the navigation out of it:-)

  • http://onereaderatatime.blogspot.com Bob Glaza

    I need to relearn long comments should be posts axiom, Mike – thanks!

  • http://www.converstations.com Mike Sansone

    Hi Bob – It’s a great way to expand the thought and extend your voice…one reader at a time:-)

  • Auctionary

    So before you sally forth with a full repetoire of twitches, nose rubs, and sly winks, all carefully practised in front of a full sized mirror, you need to get your act together and collect all of the relevant information on the properties you hope to bid for.
    auction.

  • kuril

    If everyone looked at trackbacks to benefit others, it would be put to better use. Unfortunately, too many use it to drive traffic to their own site – which is what made them a trouble spot.

Stop SOPA